Open Hearth Lodge
Comfortable rooms and a pool in Sister Bay
A place to stay in Sister Bay
Set in Sister Bay, Wisconsin, Open Hearth Lodge is a hotel. It offers a fitness center, a swimming pool and a hot tub. Room types include the King Room with Spa Bath and the King Room. Guests rate it 4.65/5 across 420 reviews.
Who this stay suits
Expect guest scores around 4.65/5.
Best for
- Travelers who want a pool
- Families with children
- Road trips & drive-up convenience
- Travelers with pets
Where you'll stay
Choose from 6 room types — including the King Room with Spa Bath, King Room, Standard Double Room. Rates start from $280 a night.
Take a dip in the pool
The pool is a welcome spot to cool off and unwind during your stay.
Around the area
Open Hearth Lodge is in Sister Bay, Wisconsin, rated 4.65/5 by guests.
Rooms & suites
King Room with Spa Bath
35 m² · 1 twin bed and 1 sofa bed
- 1 room
- Private kitchenette
- Private bathroom
- Garden view
- Pool with a view
Standard Double Room
26 m² · 2 queen beds
- 1 room
- Garden view
- Pool with a view
- Air conditioning
- Patio
Queen Room with Two
26 m² · 2 queen beds
- 1 room
- Garden view
- Pool with a view
- Air conditioning
- Patio
Deluxe King Room
30 m² · 1 king bed and 1 sofa bed
- 1 room
- Private kitchenette
- Private bathroom
- Garden view
- Pool with a view
One-Bedroom Apartment
46 m² · Bedroom 1: 1 king bed Living room: 1 sofa bed
- Entire apartment
- Private kitchenette
- Private bathroom
- Garden view
- Pool with a view
Standout features
Inside Open Hearth Lodge
Amenities at Open Hearth Lodge
Most popular facilities
- Indoor swimming pool
- Facilities for disabled guests
- Non-smoking rooms
- Free parking
- Free Wifi
- Family rooms
- Fitness center
- Tea/Coffee Maker in All Rooms
Great for your stay
- Parking
- Private bathroom
- Air conditioning
- View
- Pet friendly
- Free Wifi
- Free parking
- Flat-screen TV
Bathroom
- Toilet paper
- Towels
- Bath or shower
- Private bathroom
- Toilet
- Free toiletries
- Hairdryer
- Shower
Bedroom
- Alarm clock
View
- Garden view
- View
Outdoors
- Outdoor fireplace
- Picnic area
- Outdoor furniture
- Outdoor dining area
- Sun deck
- Barbecue
- BBQ facilities
- Patio
Open Hearth Lodge earns overwhelmingly positive sentiment across recent guests, with exceptional staff friendliness and spotless, comfortable rooms standing out as consistent highlights. Its pet-friendly amenities are genuinely best-in-class and a strong differentiator, while breakfast and the outdoor fire-pit areas add to a warm, welcoming atmosphere. Minor gripes — a small pool, dark hallways, a limited ice machine, and weak coffee — surface occasionally but do little to dent the overall experience.
- Pool is small with little deep section
- Hallways are dark
- Ice machine is small and runs out quickly
- Coffee described as too weak
- Property feels a little outdated in places
“Most dog friendly lodge we have ever stayed in—large fenced area for dogs to run, beds, bowls & toys in room, and a great grooming & bath room.”
“You'd never know it was a pet friendly place - it's that quiet and clean!!”
“The proprietor was very thoughtful and attentive. He went the extra mile in so many ways to make our experience better. Top ratings all the way.”
“It's a little outdated but I think that adds to its charm.”
Guest reviews summarised from Booking.com.
Good to know
Frequently asked
Does Open Hearth Lodge have a pool?
Yes, Open Hearth Lodge has a pool for guests.
What amenities does Open Hearth Lodge offer?
Open Hearth Lodge offers Indoor swimming pool, Facilities for disabled guests, Non-smoking rooms, Free parking, Free Wifi, Family rooms, Fitness center, Tea/Coffee Maker in All Rooms, Good Breakfast, Parking, Air conditioning, and View.
What room types are available at Open Hearth Lodge?
Room options include King Room with Spa Bath, King Room, Standard Double Room, Queen Room with Two, Deluxe King Room.
How much does it cost to stay at Open Hearth Lodge?
Nightly rates start from around $280, varying by date and room type.
Where is Open Hearth Lodge located?
Open Hearth Lodge is located in Sister Bay, Wisconsin, at 2669 South Bayshore Drive, Sister Bay, WI 54234, United States.